The Cost of Emotional Independence

Have you ever shared safe topics to avoid your true feelings?

Have you ever subconsciously tested someone’s loyalty?

Have you ever wanted closeness but found yourself pulling away the moment it arrived?

If yes then you are not alone. We all go through phases of complicated emotional experiences – most of which stem from reasons we don’t fully understand.

Kai had a normal life growing up. He went to college, made friends, and had a decent family – and yet when love tried to knock his door at different points in life, he always felt unsure.

1/ Emotional Independence vs Emotional Isolation

As Kai entered college, he became active in social circles – he played piano, joined the football team, and participated in many events.

When love entered his life for the first time, it felt magical. Everything felt nice and rosy. It was a novel experience. However, with time that magic started to slowly feel complex and heavy. It was something he wasn’t ready for just yet.

The idea of explaining his choices to someone and caring for their well-being felt overwhelming. Gradually, he began to distance himself from relationships and found joy outside of commitments.

What he didn’t realize was that he was slowly developing an avoidant attachment style – where his independence began to feel safer than emotional interdependence.

Was this entirely his doing, or did society play a role? Probably both.

We live in a culture that praises emotional strength so much that vulnerability and sharing your feelings with someone starts to feel as a mark of dependence and weakness.

Gradually, to preserve our independence we resort to isolation.

So, is vulnerability related to independence?

Can someone be vocal about their feelings and still be independent?

Probably, yes. Being open about your feelings isn’t weakness, and pretending strength while you are in turmoil isn’t strength.

Strength is being emotionally honest – while not letting those emotions consume you.

Emotional independence in healthy, emotional isolation isn’t.

2/ Illusion of Control

As Kai graduated from college and started working, he still somehow found himself trapped in shallow connections.

He longed for a genuine relationship yet couldn’t settle into one.

He kept questioning his choices – What if this isn’t the right person? What if I get heartbroken? What if my friends and family don’t approve – and many other such ifs.

It wasn’t past traumas holding him back —but a mere reflection of how he had conditioned himself to stay in control.

On the surface level, his fears sounded logical – after all, who wants heartbreak? But, at its core, it was perhaps his desire to stay in control

When someone hesitates to commit, second-guesses every attraction, or endlessly analyzes compatibility – it often reflects a deeper psychological need:

The desire to control uncertainty.

Subconsciously, Kai didn’t just want to make the right choice — he wanted to ensure he never experiences loss, failure, or heartbreak.

It gave him a temporary sense of control but, at times, it costed him real connections.

But even then, human beings are wired for connection. So, when we avoid it completely, something inside us often feels incomplete — even if we can’t label why.

3/ Label your feelings

Kai avoided commitments not because he didn’t want love – but probably because he struggled to name what he precisely felt.

He was never taught to gauge his feelings on the emotional spectrum – whether he was simply attracted, deeply interested, or in love.

One of life’s most underrated skills is the ability to precisely identify your feelings – to label them. It is something that helps us navigate our actions. 

Instead of saying “I felt hurt when you canceled our plans,” Kai would just withdraw or act irritated without understanding why.

There were times when he was sad… but he could never identify the exact shade of his sadness – was he disappointed, hopeless, or grieving.

Saying “I feel anxious and uncertain” >> just saying “I feel bad.”

When we learn to name what we feel, we learn to navigate life consciously.

Kai is not a person.

Kai is a trait that exists within all of us – at some point, in some form.

And Kai needs to be addressed, not ignored.

It needs to be addressed because finding real love requires risk, emotional surrender, and the acceptance that you can’t predict everything. And somewhere within us, Kai may be still be lingering – so next time you pull away, overthink, or silence your emotions in the name of strength, pause for a second and ask yourself – is this independence, or isolation?

Thanks for reading. Please subscribe to receive my weekly newsletter here.